I AM ALSO SO BAD WITH HORROR. I tapped out of trying to watch the Until Dawn playthrough when Mike was going to switch on the generator, because I could not cope with the possibility of a jumpscare. Believe me, I feel you on this.

But Oxenfree is so lovely! Unsettling, and occasionally distressing, but also lovely. I highly recommend it. (Plus: no jumpscares and gore. Maybe those are my issues, but I cannot overstate how much I appreciate horror with no jumpscares and no gore.)