It definitely sounds like an fun experience with the Silent Hill remake! I haven't played the games myself, but there are so many things I got into intensely as a teenager and it'd be both a good and weird experience to see them getting remade.

Living with Light would be a terrifying, if mercifully brief experience. He'd be very polite! But you'd definitely have to deal with Misa being horrifically jealous and possibly trying to murder you with her bare hands, and probably have to deal with L turning up and asking you a series of increasingly intense questions. And all the apples would mysteriously disappear! It would be an experience.