Riona (
rionaleonhart) wrote2010-10-22 07:02 pm
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Some Things Have Changed, But Can't You Tell?
Here's a scientific experiment I'd like to see: give a group of literature students at university a novel to study. Have the tutor tell them it's generally considered a great work of literature and hand out pretentious critical essays on it. Ask the students what they think of its style, its themes, the book as a whole and so on. Tell them only afterwards that in fact it is generally considered not to be a great or even a particularly good work of literature: a Mills & Boon novel, perhaps?
You'd also need a control group of students who were given the book to read without the 'we're studying this; it's a highly respected work of literature' aspect, of course, and perhaps a third group who do hear that it's a respected work but don't receive the critical essays. I think the results could be genuinely interesting, or at least mildly amusing. Really, this is a concept born of how deeply dubious I was about some of the pretentious literary criticism we had to read on my course.
On a mostly unrelated note, although I suppose he is an English teacher:

(I've just realised that Josh Stevenson's Eevee represents not only his sexual confusion but the fact that he's easily influenced; an Eevee can be led down many different paths, after all. Yes.)
I was listening to 'Elle's Theme'* from Silent Hill: Homecoming when I was uploading this image, which, naturally, made me start thinking about how Tom would fare in Silent Hill. Perhaps that's why he's matured so much by the third series: he spent the summer holidays in Silent Hill, haunted by the entire tragic Lorna arc, and emerged determined never to hurt anyone like that again. There's one to add to the frustratingly long list of Waterloo Road Fics That Won't Exist Unless I Write Them Myself, then.
* The title of this entry - some things have changed, but can't you tell? - is how I hear the lyrics at 2.30. I can't find any online transcriptions of the lyrics that share this perception - some say some things have changed, what can't be new to them and some some things have changed, what can't be mortal - but I like my interpretation more, whether it's a mishearing or not.
You'd also need a control group of students who were given the book to read without the 'we're studying this; it's a highly respected work of literature' aspect, of course, and perhaps a third group who do hear that it's a respected work but don't receive the critical essays. I think the results could be genuinely interesting, or at least mildly amusing. Really, this is a concept born of how deeply dubious I was about some of the pretentious literary criticism we had to read on my course.
On a mostly unrelated note, although I suppose he is an English teacher:

(I've just realised that Josh Stevenson's Eevee represents not only his sexual confusion but the fact that he's easily influenced; an Eevee can be led down many different paths, after all. Yes.)
I was listening to 'Elle's Theme'* from Silent Hill: Homecoming when I was uploading this image, which, naturally, made me start thinking about how Tom would fare in Silent Hill. Perhaps that's why he's matured so much by the third series: he spent the summer holidays in Silent Hill, haunted by the entire tragic Lorna arc, and emerged determined never to hurt anyone like that again. There's one to add to the frustratingly long list of Waterloo Road Fics That Won't Exist Unless I Write Them Myself, then.
* The title of this entry - some things have changed, but can't you tell? - is how I hear the lyrics at 2.30. I can't find any online transcriptions of the lyrics that share this perception - some say some things have changed, what can't be new to them and some some things have changed, what can't be mortal - but I like my interpretation more, whether it's a mishearing or not.
no subject
no subject
(I'm sure there are many song lines that broke my heart by turning out not to be the line I thought they were. I'm cursing myself for not keeping a record of my mishearings anywhere.)
no subject
Make this boy shout, make this boy scream!"
For some reason I thought it was "until we turn to the TV screen, at this point shout, at this point scream" - a comment on the cynically manufactured faux rebellion. But no. Just being a stroppy teenager.
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
Also I think your student book experiment would be both brilliant and hilarious. I half think Mills and Boon would be a bit too obvious, the absolute strict formula/pacing/length is really obvious to anyone who's read a few. But some of the romantic fiction that isn't published as mills and boon and is pretending to be better than that would be excellent.
no subject
You have a good point about Mills & Boon perhaps being a bit too transparent. Hmmm. (...I'm thinking about this as if I'm actually planning to carry it out, but I don't think that's going to happen.)
no subject
I'm fairly sure that one of these days I will write the Sherlock/Silent Hill crossover of doom, and it will be all your fault. (Also, it's really hard. I'm up to two things that actually bother Sherlock - boredom, and John being hurt, but that's not something you can base an entire town around, and for it to be a proper interesting Silent Hill, it has to be psychologically unique. John has more obvious stuff, but it's all too obvious, and I want something a bit more profound than "He was in a war, and then he came back and got kidnapped a lot."
no subject
no subject
Would it work for the two of them to be in Silent Hill together, and the town to veer between being really nasty to Watson and really fascinating for Sherlock (who meant to be keeping an eye on John, really he did, but there were so many clues) until finally John was both in rather nasty peril and not mentally together enough to handle himself, and Sherlock who'd been chasing clues was too far away and suddenly realized it, and it was this "You dragged your friend into danger, and spent the whole time trying to entertain yourself with a mystery instead of keeping a decent eye on him, and now he's going to die because of you!" guilt-moment that the town had been orchestrating the whole time?
Or has someone already done that? I'm going to read thebaconfat's fic, and it's going to turn out to have that exact plot, isn't it?
no subject
no subject
He sometimes gets disturbed by the war-murder-and-general-peril stuff, but he's shown that he can cope with all of that, so that doesn't work for the big guns. It'd have to be something a fair bit nastier, and there's so much surface-level stuff that it's hard to get a grip on what's underneath, if that makes any sense.
ETA: I've had an idea!
So, the whole place is quiet. Like spooky quiet. And neither one of them deals with the quiet and lack of action that well (monsters would be almost too easy). And there's this missing kid - no one they know, just a kid. And they're looking, and there are these screams that they hear from quite a long way away, and go chasing after. But they keep turning up too late, and there's bits of hair, and sometimes blood, and maybe, every once in a while, a finger.
Sherlock thinks it's fascinating. So many clues. So much evidence that's on the verge of adding up.
John knows that there's a kid, and he keeps being too late, and the kid's being hurt worse and worse because he's not fast enough. And he cares.
And it ties in with all of this other stuff, relating to kids he saw in the war who he couldn't help, and kids who were killed by his side as collateral damage, and people he couldn't save as a doctor, and basically all of the times he couldn't save people. And there are the usual spooky-supernatural Silent Hill coincidences, where I haven't filled in the details yet, so it all builds up to one big bundle of "People get hurt and you can't help them nearly enough, and you hurt people, because that's what you're good at" (he is an extremely good marksman, among other things), and then Sherlock's all "I'll go check the hotel, you go check down by the lake" and it all comes to a head.
no subject
You can do SO MANY things with doctors in Silent Hill. It's no wonder that James Wilson from House MD didn't make it out of all James Silent Hill I did.
That, and Wilson was being an arse on the show.
no subject
There will be monsters at some point, but not until they've been broken down enough. Put them in too early, and I think giving them something to fight would act as a release for the pressure I'm trying to build.
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
a blog describing the experiments. (http://scienceblogs.com/cortex/2007/11/the_subjectivity_of_wine.php)
Basically, wine experts were offered a glass of white wine and red wine, and were asked to describe it, EXCEPT that both glasses were the same white wine, but one glass had food colouring added. The second experiment involved pouring the same decent wine into two different bottles, one looking cheap and one looking fancy, and then asking the experts for their opinion. The results are hilarious.
no subject
no subject
It is an AMAZING read, I loved it and kept spouting the ridiculous factoids to friends. I still love the turkey mating experiment bit that was interspersed with 'oh, by the way, this young man in the 17th century was sentenced for shagging a turkey'.
But I expect that your idea would probably have a similar result, in that people go 'oh yes, interesting themes bla bla bla pretentious literary criticism' over a book that they've been told is prestigious and go 'pff, it was shite' over one they've been told isn't proper literature.
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
You could always introduce the thing by saying that you're merely studying the way alumni of English Lit respond to literature versus alumni of other areas, with a lot of 'bla bla we want to know how much knowing about English literature beforehand influences the response', something like that.
no subject
no subject
So yeah, your experiment would be really interesting, and it could also be done the other way around: tell a bunch of students that the work they're reading is crap even though it's (secretly) critically acclaimed, and then see their reactions. Personally I think people tend to be more likely to criticize something than defend it, even if they do think it's good, because they want to fit in with a society who tells them it's bad.
no subject
no subject
no subject
It would be sort of hilarious in a 101 class, though.
no subject
Lecturer: Does anyone here feel confident that they know what postmodernism means?
Entire Lecture Hall: (silence)
An entire year's worth of literature students, just bluffing their way through.)
no subject
no subject
My mum thinks this experiment is basically being done on us in reverse, since one of my courses for this year has set The French Lieutenant's Woman.
Hi there!
(Anonymous) 2012-01-29 03:52 am (UTC)(link)